Indy fans are understandably dubious about the upcoming fifthIndiana Jonesmovie, after the bitter disappointment ofKingdom of the Crystal Skull.Harrison Ford isn’t getting any youngerand the longer the producers deliberate over the script, the less necessary anotherIndiana Jonesmovie seems. When it was announced that Steven Spielberg was stepping down from the director’s chair, that skepticism grew. Spielberg’s directorial vision contributed as much to Indy’s classic adventures as George Lucas’ storytelling, John Williams’ music, and maybe even Harrison Ford’s performance.
But sinceIndiana Jones 5promises to definitively conclude the series afterCrystal Skullleft it open-ended, the fact that Lucasfilm has tappedLogandirector James Mangold to replace Spielberg as the film’s director does provide some semblance of hope. With the right script (which is apparentlythe toughest nut to crack with anIndiana Jonesmovie), Mangold can give Indy the same kind of swansong he gave Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine with a sense of finality and a poignant portrait of an aging icon.
RELATED:Fox’s X-Men Franchise Wasted A Perfectly Good Ending
When Mangold started working with Jackman on 2013’sThe Wolverine, the actor had been playing the role for over a decade. In giving his stint as Wolverine a grand finale, Mangold used all the traumas the character had amassedover the course of theX-Menseriesand presented them as emotional baggage keeping him up at night. Mangold’s Wolvie is rough around the edges. He drinks a lot, avoids making attachments after losing a few too many loved ones, and even confesses to contemplating suicide with an adamantium bullet before finding purpose in saving the next generation of mutants. The older Indy inIndiana Jones 5doesn’t necessarily need to be as hard-edged asLogan’s Wolverine – and it definitely shouldn’t be R-rated; this is a fun, lighthearted series of PG-13 actioners – but Indy might be facing a similar identity crisis at the tail end of a lifetime of liberating artifacts that belong in a museum (or in the hands of “top men”).
The big question is: will Indy die inIndiana Jones 5? Being the final movie in Indy’s on-screen arc would suggest that, like Tony Stark inEndgameor Darth Vader inReturn of the Jedior indeed Wolverine inLogan, he won’t survive to the end credits. But killing off Indiana Jones would certainly be a bold undertaking. This isn’tStar Warswith its Shakespearean underpinningsor the MCU with its cosmic genocide – it’sIndiana Jones, a series of light, fun, pulp-inspired action-adventures. The death of Indiana Jones would be one of the trickiest moments to pull off in film history. He’s a beloved cinematic icon who’s survived countless scrapes with death. Killing off Indiana Jones would be like killing off James Bond or Batman (which Christopher Nolan might have done, depending on your interpretation ofThe Dark Knight Rises).
If the producers do decide to boldly kill off Indy at the end of his latest adventure, they’re in pretty safe hands with James Mangold. Wolverine isn’t quite on the same level as Indy as a movie icon, but he certainly has Indy-level status as a comic book hero, and Mangoldnailed his death scene inLogan. Being killed by a clone of his younger self offered a poignant layer of symbolism, Hugh Jackman played both roles impeccably, and after the story built a tangible bond between Laura and her father, their final moments together resonate much more than the dramatic scenes found in the average comic book movie. Wolverine’s solemn funeral, attended by the new generation of mutants he sacrificed himself to save, inspired by a powerful scene fromShane, was a fitting ending for this character’s long, record-breaking on-screen journey.
IfIndiana Jones 5doesn’t kill off Indy, it can still have a sense of finality.Last Crusadealready gave theIndiana Jonesfranchise its perfect conclusion – acknowledged by Steven Spielberg himself before he went and made a fourth one – with Indy, his father, and his closest friends riding off into the sunset, having given up on the quest for the Holy Grail and realized what really matters. WhatIndiana Jones 5needs to do is showIndy at the end of his road.Crystal Skulltook a few meta jabs at his old age, but he was still fit to fight another day.Indiana Jones 5should catch up with Indy when he’s only got one more adventure in him.Logandidn’t shy away from portraying Wolverine’s deteriorating health and the lasting damage of each fight scene. Mangold can subvert Indy’s pulpy plot-armor invincibility in the same way he subverted Logan’s literal invincibility.
Ever since Mangoldsigned on to directIndiana Jones 5, fans have been speculating about what elements fromLoganhe’ll reuse in hisIndiana Jonesmovie and the truth is, he doesn’t need to copy anything specific fromLogan– in fact, he should probably actively avoid it.Loganwas the perfect story for Wolverine;Indiana Jones 5needs to tell the perfect story for Indy. But Mangold should still approach Indy’s final adventure with the same sense of melancholic conclusiveness he brought to Wolverine’s last stand.
MORE:Ryan Reynolds Says Deadpool 3 Was Originally Road Trip Film With Logan
